Saturday, January 16, 2010

Dramatic Facts About Schools (week 1)

Mr. Winkle Wakes

In the movie “Mr. Winkle Wakes”, by Matthew Needleman, you see that n old man wakes after sleeping hundreds of years to a world that is technology. Mr. Winkle wandered into a business filled with technology. He was disturbed by all the technology because it was new to him. He felt ill, then found a hospital to get some help and saw the computers and x-ray machines there as well. He was unable to stay in the hospital because the technology made him uncomfortable if not ill. Then Mr. Winkle found a school and went in. He felt right at home. It was just like his school a hundred years ago. He noticed that the school was using pencils and paper and the computer that was in the class was left in the back collecting dust.

My belief is, despite Mr. Needleman’s suggestion that schools should put technology to use and modernize like business organizations and hospitals, so that people depend on technology too much now when it comes to children. Yes it is good to have the World Wide Web at a child’s finger tips, but the same information can also be found going to the school’s library. Face book, for example, can be beneficial but it also can cause problems. Teens use technology too much. They fail to get outside or do not concentrate on their studies.



Did you know? 3.0

The “Did You Know?” by Kari Fisch gave me knowledge of facts that I never knew about. The fact that many things have increased in the last few years have been astonishing. Another thing that intrigued me was when Mr. Fisch said that technology coming out today can be advanced and updated by the near future. He then continued to say that the information that a freshman student in college learns about technology in school will be updated by the time that the same student reaches his or her junior year of college.

During family discussions, I heard that China and India had a lot more numbers when dealing with people population then of the United States, but it’s hard to picture these countries are much smaller in land size then ours. To also find out that China and India have so many children in cramped classrooms but are able to learn and get an education that can excel the children in the united States, that have so many resources is beyond amazing. This just tells us that every county can learn from other countries. Also, the countries that have a high number of intellectual children do not use all this high tech devices that America does.

An example of how fast technology gets updates is most video game units. By the time you save up the money to buy the unit and some games, the manufactory has come up with a new and improved unit and puts it on the market. Are we realigning on technology to much? You can’t go outside your house without seeing cell phones attached to people’s ears or computers strapped to people’s backs at schools going class to class. When all is said and done, we have to live in a world of technology that advances from one day to the next. It’s your choose if you keep up with it or not.



Ken Robinson says schools kill creativity

Ken Robinson talks and gives examples of how children in school show creativity through drawings, plays and words. Mr. Robinson also talks about how in the past before ADHD was diagnosed, they would say that if this girl wouldn’t sit still, they were a dancer. This girl went on and created musical plays that are watched and enjoyed around the world. Children use their creativity towards their imagination, and their imagination is used when they read and write. There are things that a fact that all children and adults should know is true, but when it comes to fiction and imagination, creativity should be allowed in the world and minds of every child. Creativity is a child.

I agree on when Mr. Robinson said, ‘you can’t be creative unless you are prepared to be wrong. ‘Children can make the most magnificent ideas and perception on how they see things. Schools are starting to take more creative classes, like music, art, and drama out of schools and pushing the more academic classes like math, English, History, and Science classes as the major classes. I was in school musicals and chorus from elementary school to college and the creativity that I got by this was entwined with my English and math classes. For example, to help interpret answers I used music and art to help me understand better.


Vicki Davis: Harness Your Students’ Digital Smarts

Vicki Davis talks about how she interacted into her classroom with technology and blogs so they can learn from their classmates and from other students around the world. Ms. Davis’ explains that using Google Docs can allow the accurate material to reach each student to their needs. The part of this that I enjoyed hearing about is that the students are able to learn about technology by themselves or from other classmates as they are able to learn it. It also allowed them to connect to students around the world and see different cultures and how other students in different continents use technology.

What concerns me is, are we allowing too much technology in the classroom? I understand how using certain tools to learn about different cultures right from the mouths of those other students, but I don’t entirely agree with Ms. Davis when she said that using pencil and paper does not allow students to strive. You can turn on news stations and hear them tell parents how to limit their child's computer use in a single day. To me, I think that teaching students to learn this way is keeping an excuse to stay on so long to networks.

7 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am unable to fit my entire comment in one comment space. It will be continued in the comment areas that follow.

    The point of the hospital visit in the movie was to do two things:
    1. Tell you that hospitals had changed (which you do agree with) and 2. that Mr. Winkle didn't like the changes he encountered (which you do not discuss). I would say from your comments that you missed the point of that part of the movie.

    In your second part of the discussion you suggest that we should go to the library rather than get information immediately from the clouds (Internet et. al.). Do you REALLY believe this? What a waste of time and energy and money I would argue.

    Also "I can agree and disagree" is confusing. Clarify your position your what you want to say.

    "but it’s hard to picture that these countries are so much smaller in land size then ours." What? I'm not sure what the land size of India and China has to do with either your argument or Mr. Fisch's argument, but here are the results of a quick enquiry on the Internet (not the library):

    China 3,722,029 sq. mi (includes some disputed territories) 2nd largest in world
    Unites States 3,717,813 sq. mi. 3rd largest in world
    India 1,269,219 sq. mi. 7th largest country in the world

    "The can explain how there are so many children up in orphanages in these countries because they don’t have room." Do you seriously believe this is correct? In China children end up in orphanages because if a couple has more than one child, off the excess children go. Girls go first. In India girl babies are not wanted. They end up in orphanages or just "disappear."

    Here is the amount of land area per person in these three countries:
    China 358 people per square mile 640 acres per sq. mi so about 1.8 acres per person. Not so crowded when you think of it that way.
    United States 1 person per 1.2 square miles or about 770 acres per person. Lots more room to spread out.
    India .69 acres per person. Still a bit of room to move about if we think of it that way.

    But I still don't know why it is relevant to your argument and it certainly was not part of Mr. Fisch's.

    I agree with both you and Sir Ken Robinson about this: " 'you can’t be creative unless you are prepared to be wrong.' "

    All of your post needs rewriting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I will demonstrate with your first two paragraphs covering Mr. Winkle Wakes:

    You wrote:
    In the movie of “Mr. Winkle Wakes”, by Matthew Needleman, you see that an old man wakes after sleeping hundreds of years to a world that is centered around technology. The part of this movie that I didn’t agree on was the part were Mr. Winkle went to the hospital to get some help and saw the computers and x-ray machines and said that he wouldn’t be able to receive help there. Technology has advanced in the world of medicine for the good. Without a lot of these machines and computers, people wouldn’t have had the opportunities of life that they have now. So many people died of cancer and illnesses before computers and technology had been updated and now you have people that are cancer survivors.

    The part that I can agree and disagree on in the movie is when Mr. Winkle went into the classroom. The noticed that the school was using the standard pencils and paper method and the computer that was in the class was left in the back collecting dust. I believe that so people depend on technology too much now when it comes to children. Yes it is good to have the World Wide Web at a child’s finger tips, but the same information can also be found going to the school’s library. So devices used today like face book can be beneficial but also unbeneficial. Teens are always on the networks that they aren’t getting outside or aren’t concentrating on their studies.

    In my rewrite that follows, my words are in italics. I have left out things that you should not be saying because they are digressions from the argument that the video was making. I have attempted retain what I think you intended to communicate.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The comment area will not take italics and possible not strikethroughs. I am emailing you the remainder of my comment.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You must
    Write so that you will be understood. Write short sentences. Reread them. Is your statement understandable and precise?
    Support your statements with facts.
    Make sure that you do not misinterpret the authors you are discussing nor attribute to them beliefs or statements that are not theirs.

    Rewrite this post following the above instructions. If you are to be a successful teacher you must be able to communicate clearly and convincingly in text as well as in other media.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Re: Did You Know
    "Are we realigning on technology to much? You can’t go outside your house (or inside for that matter) without seeing cell phones attached to peoples ears or computers strapped to peoples backs at schools going class to class. When all is said and done, we have to live in a world of technology that advances from one day to the next. It’s your choose if you keep up with it or not."
    The basics of reading, writing, and math are the foundation of learning. Spell check allows people to ensure they spell words like "relying" correctly only if they know that real and rely are two different things.
    Blogging for instance encourages people to practice writing, and to edit and preview work that others will see; in contrast writing an essay is final and can not be viewed or reviewed by others. Some people would consider this a great use of technology while teaching English, grammar, and creativity. If people are using computers, cell phones, and various other things in daily life then that it was appeals to them and you should attempt to engage every student by any and all means possible. What would you do with a legally blind person or a person with dyslexia? They will be in your classroom.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "Yes it is good to have the World Wide Web at a child’s finger tips, but the same information can also be found going to the school’s library"

    In Mr. Winkle Wakes, business people do not go on the internet for information, they go on line to communicate with others across the globe. Can you get the same collaboration, audience, and interaction from a visit to a school library?

    ReplyDelete